I'm rating this 5 stars for what it is. Ratings are all relative, so that is a huge factor. I have a heavy duty ball cart that has bigger wheels, holds more baseballs, and has a thicker/sturdier frame. But that one also cost a lot more. I needed a smaller cart for our pitching machine dimple balls, so we bought this to serve that purpose. For the price you can't beat what you get in this cart. It goes together easily and doesn't seem to stress when filled with baseballs. The frame is kind of thin, but unless you are really beating it up then I don't think it'll be an issue.